I'm just saying, the way I see it is the point of the challenge is to find out if royalfan is as sharp as he makes himself out to be. So if each year he's found a few plays that he's unloaded on and that have contributed significantly to his bottom line, I don't think it's fair that he can't use these plays in the challenge even though he's making them in real $ wagers.
I just think that if we're truly trying to find out how sharp he is, these plays must be accounted for. Maybe throw in a rule like he's allowed five 15-unit plays for the entire year, something like that. He said it's very rare that he makes plays much larger than the rest, so I think something like that would cover it and still make the challenge fair for all parties involved.
Again, I just think that it'd give us a more accurate depiction of royalfan's ability and how much he makes per year. Just my opinion.