Minshew 10X better than AR

Patrick McIrish

OCCams raZOR
Probably should be criminal charges drawn up on someone that Minshew was ever allowed to put on an NFL uniform.

Lombardi, Tomlin and/or Coach Dungy, no one is good enough to win with this chump taking snaps.

We move along.
 

Patrick McIrish

OCCams raZOR
Rail missed badly on Minshew but he did hit on Baker.

Of course if you call every undersized, nonathletic, white QB that reminds you of how you played you're going to hit one now and then.......

Minshew was an embarrassment to any and all who ever played in the NFL.

Justice won't be served until all mention of him ever being rostered is stricken from league rolls.

Only then can the topic of integrity in organized football even be mentioned as on the road to recovery again.
 

Woodrow Wilson

EOG Dedicated
[TABLE][/TABLE]

Rail's greater-than-Montana hero Minshew today: 15-34 154 yards, 0 td, 3 INT, 1 FUMBLE, QBR 21.0

God awful in the RZ to boot.

With even a sort of average performance today on the road he would have beaten Stafford and McVay.
 

kane

EOG master
[TABLE][/TABLE]

Rail's greater-than-Montana hero Minshew today: 15-34 154 yards, 0 td, 3 INT, 1 FUMBLE, QBR 21.0

God awful in the RZ to boot.

With even a sort of average performance today on the road he would have beaten Stafford and McVay.
minshew best QB in leage, better then montana, hes held back by dei hire coach and jew media
 

railbird

EOG Master
[TABLE][/TABLE]

Rail's greater-than-Montana hero Minshew today: 15-34 154 yards, 0 td, 3 INT, 1 FUMBLE, QBR 21.0

God awful in the RZ to boot.

With even a sort of average performance today on the road he would have beaten Stafford and McVay.
he didnt start the game, and was facing obvious 3rd and 4th and long passing downs
 

Woodrow Wilson

EOG Dedicated
Rail missed badly on Minshew but he did hit on Baker.

Of course if you call every undersized, nonathletic, white QB that reminds you of how you played you're going to hit one now and then.......

Minshew was an embarrassment to any and all who ever played in the NFL.

Justice won't be served until all mention of him ever being rostered is stricken from league rolls.

Only then can the topic of integrity in organized football even be mentioned as on the road to recovery again.

Johnny Manziel is/was another Rail HOF QB.

I thought Manziel would be productive in the NFL and whiffed.
 

railbird

EOG Master
i didnt say minshew would be great, i said he was better than AR. and for people say he was undersized i said he was same height as joe montana
 

Crazy Pete

EOG Addicted
Minshew has a niche in the NFL: as a second string, back-up quarterback.
He has been very valuable at that in the past.
But he is NOT a full time, every week starter.

Dating myself, he reminds me of Johnny Blanchard. He was a backup catcher for the 1961 Yankees, also played other positions.
He put up great numbers as a part-timer, and had a crucial Home run in the 1961 World Series. Many people consider that team one of the greatest of all time & cakewalked to the championship, but if it wasn’t for Blanchard’s 8th inning Game 3 home run, they would’ve been stuck down two games to one and in trouble against Frank Robinson and a strong Reds team.
As I recall the story, when he was traded from NY to lowly Kansas City, he was distraught in the clubhouse. His teammates tried to console him by saying that now he could be a starter, but basically he said ‘No! I’m best as a back up player!’
 

Patrick McIrish

OCCams raZOR
Yeah the Montana quote is pretty funny.

Even as a Gator I have to agree with the AR15 stuff, they're taking a great athlete and trying to make him a QB.

Works at HS level all the time, works at college level sometimes, never works at the NFL level.
 
Top