Behind-the-scenes insight on the Butler saga, Heat’s Durant inquiry, Wiggins trade, more
Fifteen behind-the-scenes nuggets on the Jimmy Butler saga that played out inside Heat headquarters during the past six weeks and Thursday’s five-team trade that ultimately shipped Butler to the Warriors and Andrew Wiggins, Davion Mitchell and Kyle Anderson to the Heat: ▪ Yes, the Heat and Phoenix Suns had a serious conversation about a trade that would have sent Kevin Durant to Miami for Butler and other assets. The Suns offered a vision of what they thought that trade should look like. The Heat presented a counter vision. The sides ultimately could not bridge the gap between the visions and both parties moved on, with Phoenix exploring other options and the Heat shifting back to discussions with the Warriors.
The Suns asked Miami for a combination of talented young players and draft picks, a rich package that Miami considered too steep, despite its admiration for Durant, who has one and half years remaining on his contract. The Heat could revisit those trade conversations if Durant asks out this summer. But Miami isn’t inclined to give up the vast majority of its best assets in a Durant deal, even though the Heat has coveted him for years. The Heat discussions with Phoenix about Durant, 36, came after a proposed three-team trade that would have sent Durant to the Warriors fell through, in part because Durant conveyed he didn’t want to return to Golden State. Durant had no issue with being traded to the Heat. But he generally preferred to stay in Phoenix, ESPN analyst and former general manager Bob Myers said after speaking with Durant recently. Phoenix then presented a Durant trade vision to the Heat. ▪ Though the Heat was opposed to clogging its books with bad or enormous contracts that extend past next season, the Heat never considered Wiggins an onerous or unpalatable contract. Miami always targeted Wiggins in discussions with Golden State because they really like him as a player. The Heat never intended to acquire Wiggins with the purpose of rerouting him to Toronto or anywhere else. The Heat views him as a highly talented two-way player who will be able to guard one of the opponent’s best wing players and offer a needed boost offensively. ▪ The Heat waited awhile for the Suns to try to find a third team that would take Bradley Beal’s contract but nothing ever got especially close. The Heat-Suns discussions were the only serious talks initially in the process. Atlanta and Washington considered taking on Beal but decided against it.
Though Miami respects Beal and appreciates his skills, the Heat gave absolutely no consideration to taking Beal’s contract because of the salary ($110 million left after this season, including $57 million in 2026-27) combined with his no-trade clause. Having a $57 million untradable contract was something the Heat wanted no part of. Miami would not have done the deal even if Phoenix offered all three of its tradable first-round picks, but it never got to that point because the Suns knew Miami wouldn’t take Beal. ▪ Though Philadelphia likely would have had interest in a Paul George-for-Butler swap, there were never any serious discussions about that. And the Heat very likely would not have done that. ▪ Though Milwaukee was linked to Butler, there were never any substantive talks of a deal to send Butler to Miami and Khris Middleton and others to Miami. The Bucks, who would have needed to dump salary to get under the second apron before any deal involving Butler, were involved in discussions with the Suns about Beal, but those never went anywhere. ▪ The Heat originally planned to send Denis Schroder and Kyle Anderson elsewhere, in part because that would have put them below the luxury tax line and in part because Miami wants to preserve flexibility in the buyout market. But Toronto changed its mind about adding Anderson when it was given an opportunity to add Brandon Ingram from New Orleans. The Heat was not angry with the Raptors because of the fluid nature of the trade deadline and because there was no firm commitment from Toronto to take Anderson. Even though the Anderson part of the deal fell through, Miami went ahead with trading Schroder because it had an agreement with Utah and didn’t want to renege. The Jazz then rerouted him to Detroit.
▪ When Miami agreed to take Schroder and send him to Utah, it did not know that adding Toronto point guard Davion Mitchell was a strong possibility. But after the Anderson deal didn’t materialize, the Heat decided that it needed point guard depth more than it needed another forward and then decided to trade P.J. Tucker (who was part of the initial Butler deal), two second-round picks and cash to Toronto for Mitchell, a player the Heat always has liked. ▪ In the hours before Thursday’s 3 p.m. trade deadline, the Heat was presented with three trade proposals that would have dropped Miami below the luxury tax. At least one was presented just before the deadline, which the team considered as 3 p.m. passed. But the Heat decided each of the three deals would worsen the roster and decided to pay the tax instead. One of those deals would have left the Heat so close to the luxury tax that adding a buyout player would have put them back over the tax, and Miami didn’t want to rule out that option. ▪ Butler’s camp this week went public with criticisms of the Heat that had been shared privately with multiple reporters in recent weeks. The Heat pushed back on several of those claims that were published by The Athletic on Friday. For starters, a Heat source denied that Miami ever offered to lessen the number of games in Butler’s original seven-game suspension and denied asking Butler to pay his own way to meet out of town with owner Micky Arison to discuss the issue. Butler and Heat president Pat Riley on Jan. 7 , and a source did not refute The Athletic’s report that Riley became emotional when he raised the topic of Butler’s late father, whose death on Feb. 8, 2024, was chronicled on a Netflix series this past October. Riley’s father, Leon, died at age 64 in 1970.
The Heat found it disrespectful that Butler’s camp characterized Riley’s demeanor as “unhinged” in that moment. Instead, the Heat viewed it as a raw, human moment from Riley and nothing that Riley was using as leverage against Butler. That portrayal particularly angered the Heat. ▪ The Heat also resented the Butler camp’s characterization of Butler dragging an undertalented team with him to two Finals appearances. A Heat source said that disregards all that Goran Dragic, Bam Adebayo, Tyler Herro, Jae Crowder and others contributed to the 2020 title run and what Adebayo, Caleb Martin, Max Strus, Gabe Vincent and others did in the 2023 run. ▪ Butler’s camp told The Athletic that Riley agreed to shorten Butler’s seven-game suspension during the Jan. 7 meeting, but a Heat source insisted Riley agreed to no such thing because the meeting with Riley did not go well. A subsequent meeting with Micky Arison and Nick Arison also did not go well, two sources said. The Heat implored Butler to be patient and play the rest of the season, but Butler’s mind was made up. He wanted out. While Butler cited how he was being used offensively, the Heat believed Miami’s reluctance to give him a max extension for 2026-27 was at the root of his anger. ▪ A Heat source said Butler was the first player who ever refused to board a flight after not being granted permission to skip the flight. Butler was suspended after missing the team’s Jan. 22 flight to Milwaukee. A Heat source said the team informed his agent, Bernie Lee, that he would not be permitted to fly separately that day, though he was occasionally granted permission to do so in the past, if the reason was considered justified.
When Butler’s camp pressed the matter, Riley reinforced that Butler did not have permission to miss the flight. Butler missed the flight anyway. Butler’s camp claimed that he was given permission in August or September to miss the flight that day to attend a promotional event for a padel tournament, but the Heat had no recollection of giving any such promise. Butler had intended to fly to Milwaukee on his own later in the evening. ▪ In the Heat’s view, everything changed with Butler when he left the Dec. 20 Oklahoma City game after appearing to sprain his ankle and cited a stomach virus. While the Heat doesn’t question if he was ill, one Heat official found it curious that he refused a COVID test. The Heat also was bothered that he posted a photo of himself playing dominoes in the team’s locker room while Miami was playing in Houston that night (Dec. 29), the third game he missed citing illness. From that point, the Heat considered Butler to be disengaged and decided to grant his trade request. ▪ On Jan. 27, Erik Spoelstra informed the team midway through practice that Haywood Highsmith would continue to start and Butler would come off the bench. Butler then left practice early, was suspended and never played for the Heat again. Multiple sources insisted the decision was entirely Spoelstra’s and was not done to punish or trigger Butler, but instead done to maintain continuity, while taking into account that Butler’s hadn’t been fully engaged in three previous appearances between suspensions. ▪ A Heat source confirmed that Butler was denied permission to return to South Florida after spraining his ankle in a Nov. 8 loss in Denver. Miami felt the return from the trip, which had four games remaining, was not justified. Riley felt it was important that he remain with the team on the road for camaradarie and other reasons.