Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

Integrity

EOG Master
guy is offering Beckett for Tillman/Penny

cheap gamble on beckett for sure, but he'd have to rebound to make it worth it as this is dynasty and tillman should be really nice

plus, penny is doing better than beckett

what do u guys think?

would like to hear some opinions on tillman himself from those that know about him
 

mofome

Banned
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

tillman is regarded as a possible #1 - but i dont think his ceiling is as high as others do. he can get it up to 95 - but works around 92. Nice curve, good change, threw a no hitter last week.

beckett had a similar era last year at this time. so not sure if there is much reason for concern or not.

you couldnt have gotten beckett for those 2 when the year started and there is a reason. i like penny back in the nl - but beckett has too much value to pass that deal up. imo
 

Integrity

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

thanks mo, i figured ud be the guy to tell me if tillman is worth keeping or not, even for beckett

gamble is very cheap, i may have to take it
 

tripp

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

agree with mo, no way you can pass up Beckett for Penny/Tillman
 

Integrity

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

thanks guys, jumped on it

got the guy to throw in a rd 4 and 1.2 of the sal difference

he ends up netting 4.5 of room, but i had 32 anyway, so the sal wasnt an issue for me
 

The X

EOG Dedicated
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

I have Beckett on my team and he's struggling.I also have Hughes so last night sucked.But at least I got one win.Beckett should turn it around in the next week or two.I would think.
 

pvcpipe

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

I think you have to make that deal. Good luck!
 

JCROM777

EOG Addicted
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

I may have jumped the gun but I dumped Beckett for Jimenez last week.
I can't pinpoint the problem but there is something wrong with Beckett.
Only time will tell if I made the right move.
 

Integrity

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

for ubaldo?

if u got ubaldo for beckett, u pulled the fleece of the year
 

JCROM777

EOG Addicted
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

If Beckett does turn things around, it could turn into a bad trade for me.
 

Integrity

EOG Master
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

If Beckett does turn things around, it could turn into a bad trade for me.


if it's keeper, ubaldo >>>> beckett

if it's one year ubaldo >> beckett

you're good either way, even if beckett turns things around

ubaldo is this year's greinke
 

The X

EOG Dedicated
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

I may have jumped the gun but I dumped Beckett for Jimenez last week.
I can't pinpoint the problem but there is something wrong with Beckett.
Only time will tell if I made the right move.

Can I play in your league?
 

JCROM777

EOG Addicted
Re: Struggling with a fantasy trade offer. Insight being sought..

One year league. I don't think I could have pulled off this trade in a keeper league.
 
Top