McNabb or Vick

[ChrisGo]

If you had to choose which qb you wanted, who's your choice.

I'm still not sold on Vick. I don't think he'll ever lead the falcons to the promise land. He's too inconsistent. Don't get me wrong he's exciting to watch, but he cannot pass the ball. I'm a falcon fan and have been all my life. I just don't see Vick being our answer.

 

[Caliente]

No brainer. Vick over Mcdummy.

 

[coconutman]

Neither. I would rather have no Qb and just run the ball.

 

[Sam Odom]

Neither! Rather have a thinking QB

 

[JJGOLD]

Both bad but I would pick Mcnab as he is a much beter thrower

 

[Jimmy Hoffa]

Neither. Timmy Chang starts for the Eagles next week.

 

[Caliente]

Mcnabb is a better thrower right to the other team.

 

[TONY MONTANA]

Give BRADY/PEYTON or BIG BEN. The other 2 choices aren't really QB's.

 

[kermit]

Both bad but I would pick Mcnab as he is a much beter thrower

Mc Nab a much better thrower ? Better than who ? He's Pathetic !

 

[Hache Man]

My gosh, McNabb easily........

He's having a rough time right now but look at what he's going though right now with the various injuries and the T.O. problems.

Most players would of ended their season already with such injuries and taken the surgery.

How soon so many forget what this guy has done in recent years.
He has carried the Eagles.....

This coming from myself, a Bucs fan, with Philly being one of our biggest rivalries in recent years......

 

[michael777]

i hate them both,but mcnabb is way better,at least he can run and has some ability to pass